• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Old Country Delicatessen: Authentic Deli Delights in Hicksville

Old Country Delicatessen is a delightful culinary gem situated in Hicksville, NY. This unassuming deli offers a rich tapestry of flavors, featuring classic sandwiches, mouthwatering appetizers, and hearty soups that evoke the warmth of home-cooked meals. With a commitment to quality and comfort, Old Country Delicatessen expertly combines traditional recipes with a welcoming atmosphere. Families and groups can enjoy outdoor seating and a cozy interior equipped with TV and Wi-Fi. Their diverse menu caters to all palates, whether you're indulging in crispy chicken wings or a fresh chopped salad. A true reflection of nostalgic dining, Old Country Delicatessen invites you to savor the taste of authenticity.

Photos & Gallery

Old Country Delicatessen: Reviews & Ratings

Amanda Otis
Amanda Otis

Fantastic experience at Tacos el Amish! This authentic Mexican restaurant offers fresh handmade guacamole and salsas and some of the best Mexican good I have ever had! A previous review from a couple months ago stated no chips and salsa, but they now have them. The staff was very friendly and attentive as well even though the restaurant was quite busy. Another previous review mentioned there were no lines on the handicap space, but that has been fixed. These owners are listening to your reviews and making changes to accommodate, and I love that! I would definitely recommend! Top notch food and service, we will visit again!

Mike Fox
Mike Fox

I am always looking for different authentic Mexican restaurants. Just happened to pass through and saw this one. Good tacos! Their complimentary appetizer plate (cucumber and radish slices) is definitely different than your typical chips and salsa. Refreshing change I suppose.

Jeff Blankenship
Jeff Blankenship

First time dining here. Was very impressed with the delicious food my wife and I ordered! Loved the creamy queso, and the rice was excellent as well. The large burrito was exactly that...large! Great value as I took half of it home. Go check them out!

Andrew Jenkins
Andrew Jenkins

Hot fresh tasty tacos, clean environment and nicer than the places in Fort Wayne. Our new favorite place for authentic Mexican Tacos. Just as good today as the first time a few years ago keep up the great food.

Alex Bennett
Alex Bennett

My group of 4 had the restaurant to ourselves for dinner a few nights ago. This is not a typical Mexican restaurant as they do not serve chips and salsa when you sit down. They have cucumbers, radish, and an assortment of non-typical Mexican restaurant salsas. Unfortunately on our visit they were out of cheese. Came as a surprise to me that a taco place could possibly run out of cheese so I chose not to eat. My friends each had tacos and thought they were good, but not worth going out of our way to come back. Service was good, and prices were also pretty good.

Tridwip Sen
Tridwip Sen

I've been to Mexico a month back. So I know what authentic Mexican foods taste like. To be honest, this is the first restaurant in US I've been to that serves foods close to authentic Mexican taste. The environment inside also gives a true Mexican vibe. Try their guacamole sauce which they make live infront of you.

Craig A.
Craig A.

This is a text book old school Deli. It's not about ambiance, atmosphere or even service with a smile. It sometimes feels like a good old German steakhouse where the service is cold but the food is great. Hands down, the best egg sandwiches in the neighborhood. What I like about this place is that they don't try to be gourmet and make everything more fancy than good. They just serve the classics And they do it well. All the way down to the muffins baked on premises. When you order a sandwich here you get a real sandwich. Not some kind of sissified mockery on artisan bread with 2 pieces of meat and a bunch of lettuce, you get a real sandwich. It's food prepared by people who like food.

Zaneta O.
Zaneta O.

I ordered breakfast from Old Country Delicatessen through Grubhub because I wanted to try a new deli in the area. When I went to pick it up my gps sent me on a wild goose chase so I pulled over at the gas station and called them up. They told me they were location in the shopping center right across the street from where I pulled over. I walked in and the first thing I noticed is they are very well staffed. I counted at least 6 employees on duty at the time. The deli counter is quite long and takes up practically the entire right hand side of the store until you reach the cashier. They have a good variety of both fresh and pre-made foods and plenty of drinks and snacks too. The guys working there seemed cool. My sandwich was good, precisely as I'd ordered it. They did not forget to include my oj, napkins and a straw in the brown paper bag. The bacon on my bacon egg and cheese was nice and crisp and they prepared it this way without having to be told to do so. No one likes soggy bacon! Eggs were great, cheese was melty and the poppyseed roll was soft and fresh. It was a very enjoyable sandwich. I will be back to try some of their lunch offerings.

Location

Welcome to the delightful world of Old Country Delicatessen, a hidden gem nestled in Hicksville, NY. This unclaimed deli is a culinary oasis that combines tradition and innovation, offering an extensive menu of delicious sandwiches and special dinners sure to satisfy any craving.

Located at 200 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, Old Country Delicatessen prides itself on using quality ingredients to whip up delectable dishes. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch, a takeaway meal, or a cozy dinner with family and friends, this deli has something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Old Country Delicatessen is its impressive array of paninis. Each creation bursts with flavor, like the Wantagh Panini—a mouthwatering assembly of chicken cutlet, tomatoes, crispy bacon, and fresh mozzarella, all for just $9.50. For those craving a taste of Italy, the Sicilian Panini, loaded with prosciutto, Genoa salami, provolone, and roasted peppers, offers an undeniable appeal at $8.95. Vegetarians can revel in the Vegetarian Panini, which features asparagus, tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil for just $7.95.

The carving board menu boasts heartier options. The Gobbler is a festive delight with fresh turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing, and gravy, all stacked on a roll for $9.25. Meanwhile, meat lovers will find joy in the Steak Tid Bits, where sliced steak meets melted mozzarella for a mere $10.95, promising an indulgent experience.

Old Country Delicatessen doesn't stop at sandwiches; their special dinner offerings also shine. The Chicken Francese and Chicken Marsala, both priced at $12.99, redefine comfort food with their rich flavors and hearty portions. Seafood enthusiasts can treat themselves to the Shrimp Scampi at $14.99, while the Eggplant Parmigiana sits attractively on the menu at $9.99 for a healthy yet indulgent alternative.

This deli understands the importance of a warm and inviting atmosphere. With ample outdoor seating, family-friendly utilities, and complimentary Wi-Fi, it’s a perfect spot to gather with loved ones or unwind solo. Plus, they take reservations and accept credit cards, adding convenience to your experience.

In essence, Old Country Delicatessen strikes a perfect balance between comfort and innovation. The flavors resonate with every bite, and the welcoming ambiance invites patrons to linger a little longer. If you're nearby, don’t miss out—call (516) 935-2700 and treat yourself to a culinary adventure you won't soon forget!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • No delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards